![]()
Metafísica y persona. Filosofía, conocimiento y vida. Año 16, Núm. 32,
Julio-Diciembre, 2024, ISSN: 2007-9699, DOI: 10.24310/metyper322024
76
-
tivation. For even if it is true, as Larmore notices, that generous acts cannot
be reduced to the plain fact that they cause certain feelings of approval in
our motivational set, as some Humeans would simplistically put it, it is no
it not for the sentiments of gratitude that we usually develop towards their
authors. So, to bring Strawson’s account into focus, there are certain feelings
something that can come up for review as particular cases can come up for
79
-
including gratitude, of course, but also resent-
-
tude is the one that we tend to adopt towards agents who are under some sort
of mental abnormality, in which case we suspend our typical reactions, for
they would be quite inappropriate. Now, compare such an objective stance
with Larmore’s impersonal perspective, the one we would need to adopt for
assessing the existence of moral reasons. Aren’t they too similar in some re-
spect? Needless to say, Strawson’s paper is not concerned (or, at least, not di-
reasons. But it is certainly concerned with moral-
ity, even to the point of qualifying as moral
Indeed, it seems that it would be rather strange if, in accordance with his own
conceptual scheme, a reason to be generous, for instance, had nothing to do
he may fear that if my reason to be generous with my dearest cousin rests on
the love I feel towards him, then it could never be possible to have a similar rea-
son to be generous with someone for whom I have no such a feeling. However,
this would be a complete distortion of the phenomenon. Truly enough, nobody
F., Freedom and Resentment and Other Essays,
14.
79
F., Freedom and Resentment…, p. 10.
F., Freedom and Resentment…, p. 13.
F., Freedom and Resentment…, p. 10.
See, for instance, F., Freedom and Resentment…, p. 21.